Lead in protein powder
Lead in protein powder became a real buying question after Consumer Reports tested 23 powders and shakes in October 2025. More than two-thirds went over CR’s 0.5µg-a-day level of concern in a single serving, and the plant products, all pea-based with no hemp tested, averaged nine times the lead of the dairy ones. Here’s what those numbers mean.
What Consumer Reports found
CR tested 23 dairy, beef, and plant products across two to four lots each. About 70% exceeded 0.5µg lead in one serving. Two plant powders hit 7.7µg and 6.3µg. Plant products averaged nine times dairy and twice beef. Cadmium and inorganic arsenic showed in a few; mercury did not at levels of concern. Vanilla vs chocolate was not meaningfully different in this round.
Where the lead comes from
Lead is in soil and water; plants take some up, so a concentrated plant scoop can carry more. Processing and crop origin can add more. Hemp is efficient at pulling metals from soil. In one polluted-soil trial, hemp seeds took up more cadmium and nickel than lead (Linger et al., 2002), so for hemp check cadmium as carefully as lead.
The benchmarks, and why they differ
| Benchmark | Lead | Cadmium | What it is |
|---|---|---|---|
| Prop 65 safe harbor | 0.5µg/day | 4.1µg/day | California warning line; CR’s lead concern level |
| FDA interim reference | 2.2µg kids; 8.8µg women of childbearing age | n/a | Whole diet, not one product |
| NSF dietary supplement | 10µg/day | 4.1µg/day | NSF cert limit as reported by CR |
No safe level of lead is identified. Prop 65 is the strict line most buyers use to compare scoops. FDA’s figure is total diet, so a powder that uses a big share leaves less room for other food.
How to read a heavy-metals result
Labs report ppm (mg/kg) or ppb (µg/kg). Convert to µg per serving: from ppb, multiply by grams in the scoop and divide by 1,000; from ppm, multiply by grams. Example: 20ppb × 35g ÷ 1,000 = 0.7µg lead (140% of Prop 65). “Not detected” only means below that lab’s limit. A “<10ppb” on 35g means <0.35µg; “<100ppb” means <3.5µg and is much less useful.
Cantein’s Eurofins results
| Metal | Result | Per 35g scoop | Vs Prop 65 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lead | 6.28ppb | 0.22µg | 44% of 0.5µg |
| Cadmium | 14.0ppb | 0.49µg | 12% of 4.1µg |
| Arsenic (total) | 29.7ppb | 1.04µg | ~10% of 10µg if all inorganic |
| Mercury | Not detected (<5ppb) | <0.18µg | Below detection |
Eurofins tested the hemp protein in Cantein by ICP-MS in September 2025. Unflavored is 100% that protein, so a 35g scoop matches the sample. All four metals sat under Prop 65, FDA, and NSF lines in the benchmarks above. Full report: email info@cantein.com. Buying-guide version: third-party tested protein powder.
Limits of one sample: metals vary by soil and harvest; arsenic was total, not inorganic-only; Vanilla and Chocolate weren’t tested as finished products (less hemp per scoop, but cocoa can carry metals).
How to choose a lower-lead powder
- Ask for per-lot results with lab name, units, and detection limits for lead, cadmium, arsenic, and mercury.
- Convert to µg per serving; compare with 0.5µg lead and 4.1µg cadmium.
- Organic does not mean low metals. USDA Organic does not set soil heavy-metal limits.
- Watch serving size. A double scoop doubles the dose.
- Mix protein sources across the week. Be more careful in pregnancy or for children; CR favors food over powders where possible for those groups.
Which one to buy
Choose a brand that publishes lot-level heavy-metal numbers you can convert to µg per scoop. Cantein’s September 2025 hemp sample was 0.22µg lead per 35g scoop. Shop Cantein hemp protein.
- Consumer Reports. Protein powders and shakes contain high levels of lead, October 2025. consumerreports.org
- FDA. Lead in food and foodwares. fda.gov
- OEHHA. Proposition 65 safe harbor levels: lead and cadmium.
- Linger P et al. Industrial Crops and Products, 2002. doi.org/10.1016/S0926-6690(02)00005-5
- Eurofins Food Chemistry Testing Madison. COA 5085772-0, September 24, 2025. Available from info@cantein.com
Related: How Cantein is made and tested · Third-party tested · All Learn pages
